RFID? Trust Us. We’re Experts.
Could broad anti-RFID laws cause problems?, by Anne Broache CNET News.com. July 14, 2005.
This article discusses radio frequency identification (RFID) tags and possible limits on their use being proposed by law makers. The article reports on
a panel discussion ‘designed to address the outcry from “Luddite privacy people who don’t like this new technology.”‘ The panel was hosted by the American Electronics Association (motto: “Advancing the Business of Technology”). When problems were discussed, “panelists said they weren’t worried.” Thirteen federal government agencies are currently using or plan to use the technology including the Government Printing Office (see: Contactless traveling By Maury Wright, EDN, 7/7/2005).
There are three things that worry me about many discussions of technology policy. First when those in favor of technological change use ad hominem arguments and terms like “Luddite” rather than address issues. Second, when self-appointed experts say they aren’t worried. Third, when “discussions” are hosted by true believers and business interests. Check. Check. Check.
For some other views and more about RFID, see
“RFID opposition news” at wikipedia and No RFIDs at SF Public Library at LibrarianActivist.org, July 11, 2005.