The Time Has
Come: Taking Our Issues to the Public by Peter G. Neuman, (Sun, 28
Aug 2005) The Risks Digest Volume 24: Issue 2.
How are we doing with our information infrastructure? Is everything moving
along well and in the right direction? Peter Neuman, speaking of
computer risks in general, notes that
the “basic problems” keep recurring. “Whatever progress
might be made in computer-related technologies and their applications
has not been reducing the threats, vulnerabilities, and risks related to
the systems upon which we individually and as a civilization depend
most.”
He says that it is time for risks-aware professionals to reach
out to others and continues:
I have testified at least a dozen times for governmental
bodies on RISKS-related issues, but always have a gnawing feeling that
these efforts fall on deaf ears or are largely ignored by brains that
are preoccupied with other concerns.
What are these computer-related risks? They include failures of hardware
and software to behave as we expect them to and result in everything
from the destruction of the space shuttle Challenger in 1986 and a
defense system mistaking the rising moon for incoming missiles in 1960,
to radiation overdoses administered by computer-controlled
radiation-therapy machines and the collapse of a hospital computer
system brought on by a date change. They include problems of
reliability, security, and privacy. The occur in systems large and
small and with result that are laughable and life-threatening. They
include human behavior (malice, incompetence, carelessness, lack of
experience) as well as the “inherent limitations both of the technology
and of the people who interact with it.”
How does this relate to libraries and information? Neuman has noted
that, as the future leads us to a worldwide information infrastructure
(WII)…
National cultural identities may become sublimated.
Governments will attempt to regulate their portions of the WII, which
attempts could have chilling effects. Commercial interests will
attempt to gain control. Aggregation of geographically and logically
diverse information enables new invasions of privacy. Huge volumes of
information make it more difficult to ensure accuracy. The propagation
of intentional disinformation and unintentionally false information can
have many harmful effects.
(Compter-Related Risks, p300)
For more than 20 years, Neuman has been moderating the
mailing list The Risks
Digest (a “Forum On Risks To The Public In Computers And Related
Systems” of the Association for Computing
Machinery Committee on Computers and Public Policy) that
addresses such risks. He wrote The Book on the topic, Computer-Related Risks (New York,
New York : Reading, Mass. : ACM Press ; Addison-Wesley, 1995). Neuman
and contributors to the Digest document problems that “relate to
the roles that computers and communication systems play in our lives.”
This is a call for action and for help. Neuman says,
…those of us who worry about risks, hype, propaganda, distortions, and
the general demise of scientific and realistic thinking have been
outflanked by well-funded, vested interests who have everything to gain
from maintaining the status quo. Further, making real progress against
such entrenched forces means moving outside of the confines of
preaching-to-the-choir Internet mailing lists and Web sites.
Neuman invites
individuals and organizations that might be interested
in helping to to get in touch with him (neumann@csl.sri.com) or
Lauren Weinstein (lauren@vortex.com).